16 votes

What is required for a "there is no such program" answer to be high quality?

To give such an answer, either you must be pretty profient in that area to be sure – or the question must be a "little stupid". In both cases, an answer should not be limited to "there is no such ...
  • 18.5k
13 votes

Are we becoming lax about answer quality?

I think you are totally right. I tend to downvote such answers, I will go over to flag them as well (as VLQ as suggested by Gilles). Usually I care more about questions then answers so I didn't ...
  • 3,020
11 votes
Accepted

Is suggesting built-in software acceptable?

In the past, this was done. And I don't see anything wrong with that – after all it's software "available", and in cases like that the user could even skip the download+install part. But in your ...
  • 18.5k
9 votes
Accepted

Random inappropriate necro-deletion of decent, helpful, upvoted answer

What you don't see is the six other poor quality and sometimes actually spammy answers there. Granted its a video conversion question, and they attract spammers. You're not one. Awesome. We've ...
9 votes

Is suggesting python libraries/solution a proper software recommendations?

Almost never ideal, but perhaps preferable to no answer at all? As someone who does enjoy writing code I would be sad to see such answers go because I find them empowering, but that is not the ...
  • 382
9 votes

Is suggesting python libraries/solution a proper software recommendations?

To me it's OK as long as the OP explicitly stated "if some coding is involved with Python, that would be acceptable" (see: Is it okay to ask for algorithms on this site?). If no coding skills are ...
  • 18.5k
8 votes

Is source code an acceptable answer?

We've had a somewhat similar question in the past: Are answers which provide a complete script acceptable? As I write, the top two answers are: [+5] I would say that we probably shouldn't be giving ...
5 votes

Providing answers to questions that will obviously be closed

Don't answer questions that you think should be closed and can't be salvaged. Answering is wasting one's time. For the license question, I guess that Izzy just felt generous and wanted to ...
  • 18.9k
5 votes

Is source code an acceptable answer?

In my answer, I referred to iText, which is a PDF library. See also Free or nearly free PDF library for Java Due to the very specific requirements of the OP, I don't think that there's a solution that ...
5 votes

Random inappropriate necro-deletion of decent, helpful, upvoted answer

While I see your point of "no warning before" – I also see the point of the mod deleting the post. I'm not a mod; if I had "pushed that button" you'd have gotten a warning in advance (and a chance to ...
  • 18.5k
4 votes

How to handle "it's impossible" answers?

I think that we should we allow "It's impossible" answers for the following reasons: Such answers are useful to inform the OP and other readers of the difficulty or impossibility to provide ...
4 votes

Why was this answer deleted?

You need to have personal experience with software that you recommend, as per the answer quality guidelines. Your answer essentially falls in the 'I Googled your query and found this' section as of ...
  • 4,235
4 votes

Random inappropriate necro-deletion of decent, helpful, upvoted answer

Everyone else has already covered the pertinent points here, so I'm going to try to give a little context for this (not in strict chronological order, though): Way back in the beginning of the site, ...
  • 4,235
4 votes

Random inappropriate necro-deletion of decent, helpful, upvoted answer

This deletion was entirely appropriate. Before accusing others of being “rogue”, please take a minute to inform yourself about our site. The fact that the answer had been around for a while changes ...
4 votes

Edit otherwise valid answer to remove "Also, look at that long list of maybe solutions"?

Good observation, Nicolas. When I see that type of answer, I often wonder "What is wrong with the answer that they decided to also include a link to a list of apps?". I then reread the answer at ...
3 votes

How to handle one line answers vs comments

The second category ("Try software XYZ, it will work well.") lacks the info whether it meets the requirements at all (if I ask for a boat and get told a car "works well", it doesn't help me at all) – ...
  • 18.5k
2 votes

How we should deal with seemingly easy questions

My own answer to this question is based on Alecos Papadopoulos' answer to a similar issue on Economics SE. Such questions: a) Can very easily come out as "too broad", and for this matter should be ...
  • 1,124
2 votes

Edit otherwise valid answer to remove "Also, look at that long list of maybe solutions"?

I find RockPaperLizard's paragraph about "lacking answers" very true. Answers that have such links are often lacking something else. Often the answer would otherwise be a one-line answer (which ...
  • 18.9k
2 votes

How to handle "it's impossible" answers?

Such answers should be allowed and if there is an explanation why it's impossible such answer can be really useful. So, some example for a question with an "it's not possible" answer could ...
  • 490
2 votes

Answers with broken links to software that is no longer available

This is one of the reasons that we discourage product recommendations on super user. In many cases the author is gone so pinging the author might not be a good solution on its own. To me If its a ...
1 vote

How to handle "it's impossible" answers?

I don't want such answers. They don't help me. And thus I downvote, because that's exactly what the downvote means: "it is not useful". When I ask a question, I have a problem and I want to ...
1 vote

Should I flag answers that contain multiple, independent solutions?

As we want software recommendations (instead of merely software mentions), an answerer that has multiple solutions in mind would ideally compare these solutions, and recommend when to use which. I ...
  • 7,780
1 vote

Quality guidelines for software identification questions/answers?

I think we should just close software identifications questions. Here's why: They don't have requirements There can only be 1 correct answer Answers which suggest similar software will just be ...
  • 6,700
1 vote

You're doing it all wrong!

Four points: When a question gets no answers, most askers would prefer link-dropping to something they were not aware of to having no answer at all. Requiring personal experience decreases the ...
  • 2,972

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible